In this edition of the Coffin Corner we take a look at the biggest fantasy games from players who were left riding the Pine Pony instead of the starting lineup and the ripple effect of the mistake. Every year there are monster games left on the bench, such as Ronnie Brown’s 5 Touchdown performance against the Patriots when the Wildcat was unveiled. These games are big because a huge game left on the bench might be the difference between a win and a loss, or might be the difference in a tiebreaking scenario in the playoffs. I didn’t include a player if they scored a ton of points, but were outperformed by the starter, such as if Mike’s backup QB had 50 points the week Vick had 57 points.
10. Matt Ryan – (Week 7) 30.46 Points
Matt Ryan threw for 300 yards and 3 TDs against the Bengals in Week 7. Kevin lost this game to Hurst by less than 2 points, so the difference in points between Matt Ryan and Kyle Orton would have been enough for Kevin to win. This would have dropped Hurst from 8-5 to 7-4 and he would have had the 5 seed rather than the 4 seed, meaning that his first round game would have been on the road instead of at home against Jimmy… okay, so basically nothing significant would have changed.
9. Matt Forte – (Week 5) 31.8 Points
Forte had almost 200 all-purpose yards and 2 TDs against the Panthers in week 5, but Nick had given Peyton Hillis the nod in the starting lineup this week. Nick had gotten Kevin on an off week and stuck it to him beating him by almost 60 points, so the additional points would have done nothing other than embarrass our league commissioner a little bit more. No effect on the standings occurred because of these missed points.
8. Peyton Hillis – (Week 9) 33.5 Points
The New England Patriots basically rolled through most of the regular season, minus a few speed bumps. The Cleveland Browns were one of those speed bumps. Hillis had 220 all purpose yards and 2 TDs, but Nick has started Matt Forte over Hillis this week (basically the exact opposite of Week 5). Nick was lucky that the rest of his team had a great day and that Joey couldn’t keep up with him, even with Hillis on the bench. The points didn’t have a bearing on the tiebreakers, so Nick wasn’t punished for missing the extra points.
7. Keiland Williams – (Week 10) 33.9 Points
Sometimes it’s nice to have running backs from the same team when they use a running back by committee, but when you start the running back that has 0 points and you bench the back that has 3 TDs and 140 yards you tend to regret it. That is exactly what happened to Brendan “the Fresh Prince” Feifer (thank god for that memory at Stump the Schwab). Luckily for Feifer he cock-slapped John by 50 points, but the extra 33 would have nice to embarrass Johnny Boy. These points had no bearing on the playoff seeding.
6. Jay Cutler – (Week 12) 35.58 Points
Not many people can say they truly believed that Jay “Redzone Interception” Cutler would throw for 250 yards and 4 TDs against the Eagles, so it’s hard to fault Mike for giving Vick the start. Mike ended up pulling off a 2 points squeaker over Hurst, so had he started Cutler he may have saved himself a little bit of stress, but nonetheless, these extra points didn’t hurt Mike on the bench.
5. Kyle Orton – (Week 10) 35.74 Points
Kyle Orton had a huge day this week, throwing for nearly 300 yards and 4 TDs against the Chiefs. This would not have had too much of an effect on the season since Kevin would have still won this game and just outscored everybody else by a few more points at the end of the year. Luckily for me, Orton threw a few TDs to Brandon Lloyd during this game, so I’ll just thank you Kevin for helping me win this week.
4. Darren McFadden – (Week 14) 40.4 Points
This was the second time of the season that Darren McFadden punished me for not starting him. It felt like every time I turned my head to the Oakland game, DMC was making his way into the end zone, and my hopes of beating Kevin in the playoffs were dying. Little did I know McFadden was just giving us all a wonderful gift in the form of the greatest Fantasy Football finish of all time. Had I started McFadden, I would have blown Kevin out of the water and advanced to the semis with ease, but instead I was forced to rely on Matt Schaub and Neil Rackers to basically outscore the dynamic duo of Adrian Peterson and Arian Foster with their trusty sidekick Derrick Mason. This is a tall task for anyone, but Schaub and Rackers proved worthy and helped carry me to a win in true David vs. Goliath fashion.
3. Matt Cassel – (Week 10) 41.06 Points
Matt Cassel was a late season pick up during this week and showed me that I should not have hesitated to put him into the starting lineup. Cassel threw for 469 yards and had 4 TDs, which showed me that he probably deserved to start down the stretch, especially with the chemistry he and Dwayne Bowe had been building. These points left on the bench would have put me into 7th place over John and would have gotten me eliminated in the first round instead of the semi finals. John would have lost to Jimmy in the semis after beating Kevin.
2. Kenny Britt - (Week 7) 44 Points
Kenny Britt exploded this week with 225 Receiving yards and 3 TDs and it really hurt John because Mike Thomas had -2 points and Wes Welker had 4.5 points. Had Britt been placed in the lineup for either one of them, John would have beaten Mike and had the 6th seed in the playoffs. Nick would have fallen to 7th, but it didn’t matter too much, since both Nick and John would have still been eliminated in the first round of the playoffs.
1. Darren McFadden – (Week 7) 44.6 Points
This was Darren McFadden’s break out performance this year. McFadden looked like a man possessed against the Broncos, scoring 4 TDs on 196 all-purpose yards. Although I won the game, McFadden would have replaced Rashard Mendenhall who only got 4.6 Points this week, giving me 40 more points on the year, which would have made me the 7 seed and John the 8 seed for the playoffs due to the tiebreaker. Assuming the same playoff point totals, I would have lost to Mike in the first round of the playoffs, John would have beaten Kevin in the first round and then would have lost to Jimmy, thus keeping the end result of the season the same.
Editor’s note: As I was putting this together, I thought more of these games would have been effected by the points on the bench, but for the most part it really had no bearing on the final outcome of the league.