This installment of the Coffin Corner features the Top 10 busts/disappointments from last year’s draft.
10. Walking Wounded – DeAngelo Williams/Tony Romo/Sydney Rice/Ryan Grant
It’s hard to classify players who get injured as a “bust”, so I grouped a bunch of them together for this spot in the rankings. Whenever a player you drafted in the first 3 rounds gets injured, your team feels the effects of that. Grant was the only one that didn’t see any action this year, but all were injured before making any real contributions to their teams. Unfortunately it’s impossible to predict if a player is going to get injured while doing the draft, unless you pick Chad Pennington, who is built like a piece of wet spaghetti.
9. Ronnie Brown – Round 4 Pick 46 to Jimmy
140.1 Points
Ronnie Brown and Ricky Williams had been a dynamic duo over the past couple of seasons, both racking up yards and TDs and just thriving in the Wildcat offense. Unfortunately, the Dolphins passing offense lacked the explosiveness needed to prevent teams from piling 8 men in the box every play. Brown didn’t have a terrible season, but owners wanted more out of the starting running back for a team that relies heavily on the run game.
8. Robert Meachem – Round 5 Pick 50 to Jimmy
117.2 Points
Robert Meachem wasn’t a “bust” per-say, but he was the 2nd of the New Orleans Saints’ wide receivers taken in the draft and didn’t have quite the season that Lance Moore had. It was impossible to know that the Saints were going to be playing Wide Receiver roulette to see who would be the go to receiver for the week, but owners who put their chips on Meachem over the other WRs lost more often than they won. Meachem gave a few solid performances, but was far from spectacular.
7. Jonathan Stewart - Round 4 Pick 48 to Feifer
101.3 Points
Jonathan Stewart was never the featured back in Carolina and Feifer did not draft him here with that expectation. DeAngelo Williams is the go to back and then Stewart was supposed to frustrate Williams’ owners by stealing his TD at the goal line. When Williams got hurt, it was time for Stewart to be more than a goal line back, but he never could get anything going. It also didn’t help that the Carolina Panthers had one of the worst Offenses in recent NFL memory, resulting in a subpar season for Stewart.
6. Ryan Mathews – Round 3 Pick 32 to John
129 Points
I know that each and every one of us remembers NFL.com telling us that the next player that we should take was Ryan Mathews from the end of round 1 to the time John pulled the trigger on him. Now he wasn’t AWFUL, but I think it’s safe to assume that Mathews owners wanted to see a little bit more out of a Running back taken in the early rounds. It also doesn’t help when your QB throws 40 TDs, half of which go to Antonio Gates. Mathews may turn out to be an elite Running back, but it was a little too high to draft the rookie back.
5. Steve Smith - Round 4 Pick 39 to Gill
87.3 Points
The Carolina midget Steve Smith punched more people in the face than he scored fantasy points last season. That’s not entirely true, but he had an absolutely dreadful season last year. It probably wasn’t entirely his fault since Matt Moore turned out to be terrible at QB, the Offensive Line couldn’t block a Mustangs team, and the Running game was just mediocre without DeAngelo Williams, which allowed teams to double team Steve Smith and allow him nothing all season. Add in a sprained wrist and you’ve got yourself one heck of a down year for the usually reliable Smith.
4. Shonn Greene – Round 2 Pick 13 to Terrono
104.6 Points
Shonn Greene was supposed to put the “Pound” in the Jets’ “Ground and Pound” run game. Greene showed that he clearly was not ready to have the running load put on his shoulders, as old man Tomlinson had the superior season to the second year back out of Iowa. Fumbling problems and just an all around lack of the big time play making ability shown in his rookie season made Terrono look foolish for selecting Greene with the first pick of the 2nd round.
3. Devin Aromashadu – Round 6 Pick 63 to Gill
19.9 Points
Honestly, I have no idea what I was thinking when I made this pick. I was doing a little bit of research and read that a lot of analysts were pretty high on him as a sleeper pick, but in my paranoia that someone else would take him first and he’d have a stellar year, I took him in the 6th round. What a horrible mistake that turned out to be. The guy couldn’t get on the field for a team that has about ½ of a legitimate WR in Johnny Knox and he averages a measly 1.32 points a game. If I had taken him in the 9th or 10th round I wouldn’t have been that upset, but for the 6th pick on my team, this is just disgraceful. Shot for the stars and missed by a mile.
2. Beanie Wells – Round 3 Pick 35 to Lukas
61.6 Points
It’s not difficult to figure out what went wrong here. Chris Lukas chose a Running back for the Cardinals. Nothing about that sentence hints at success. Beanie Wells was coming off a strong rookie season for the Cards, but Kurt Warner was dancing with the stars and Matt Leinart was too shitfaced to know that it was football season, meaning that every Cardinal was going to have a bad year (except Larry Fitz because I don’t think he’s human). Wells couldn’t get anything going and ended up losing his starting role to Tim Hightower. Hightower ended up having a few big games here and there while Wells ended up doing nothing.
1. Randy Moss – Round 2 Pick 19 to Hurst
83.3 Points
When you are the greatest deep ball wide receiver in NFL history, no one really cares about your attitude because they know you’re going to ball out every game and be an ass doing it. Unfortunately for Randy Moss owners, Moss decided to go with the “I have a shitty attitude AND I’m going to catch nothing in the process”. He traveled from Patriots to Vikings to Titans to Bench. You felt the need to start him week in and week out because he was your #1 WR and you could always tell yourself that he just had an off week being covered by the likes of Darrell Revis and Vontae Davis, but he only rewarded you with more Goose Eggs in the Point column than you want to remember. When you’re rated as a Top 3 WR in the league and you put on that kind of performance, you are officially the biggest bust of the draft.